A former-LDS friend found some notes on apologist tactics and shared it with me, and I just HAD to pass it along. Enjoy!
1.
Apologists start with the end in mind, and sift through available
evidences, picking and choosing what they will use to construct an
argument to support their previously determined conclusion.
2.
Ad hominem attacks - when frustrated, apologists will typically attack
the character or credentials of a critic, trying in some way to minimize
the perceived credibility of the arguments of the critic.
3.
Straw man construction - destruction. Apologists will take several of
the weakest aspects of the critics argument, glue them together as if
they are the entire argument, then proceed to attack the straw man
characterization of the argument. This approach is used to discredit the
entire argument and is fallacious. It relies on a logic that says, if
this little part may be refuted, the rest of the argument is null and
void.
4. Improper usage of sources, often using secondary sources as primary sources - also using sources out of context.
5.
The lynchpin - invalid epistemology. If all else fails, the "spiritual
witness" card is pulled, saying that it all relies on faith, or "once
you have a spiritual witness, nothing can take that away." They fail to
address the inherent circular logic or infinite regress that that
causes. Why would a burning in the bosom, or feeling of peace be an
indication of truth? Because the scriptures tell us so. How do we know
the scriptures are telling us the correct way to find the truth? Because
they are from God and God wouldn't lie to us. How do we know the
scriptures are from God? Because the scriptures tell us so. Thus starts the
endless loop.
Indeed. Better put on the armor of God if you're going up against a Hugh Nibley-type from FAIR! Good luck!
Welcome to My Continuing Online Journey!
Perhaps you've read my book by now, or maybe you've only heard of it and were curious about me, or maybe you're even just surfing the web and happened on one of my posts, but please take your time and wander around. I've got enough to say, I'll be posting for some years yet! Lots of resources, personal entries, and discussion to be had; please contribute (respectfully) to it without fear of being lambasted. (Read: all comments will be moderated for relevance and basic appropriateness.) Finally, if you are here because you have heard my story or one like it and are willing to lend your support to us indoctrinated folk entering the real world, Thank You. With love, Regina
Saturday, March 30, 2013
Bless the Ex-Mormon Community!
Labels:
ad hominem,
apologist,
circular thinking,
context,
epistemology,
lds church,
Mormon,
sources,
tactics
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
I will approve all respectful and appropriate comments to this blog. However, if your comment does not get approved, please keep in mind I am busy running a household and cannot respond excessively. Thank you.